CO129-226 - Acting Governor Marsh - 1886 [4-5] — Page 360

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

356

3

Poking had an object in view, and that object could have been none other than that he should require the Mandarin dialect. But surely it was never intended that Mr. May should be paid out of public funds - funds voted by the Legislative Council and the expenditure of which was approved by the Secretary of State - to devote more than to learning Mandarin only to unlearn it on his return to the Colony, for such will be the inevitable result if he is not assisted by the Government in keeping up the knowledge he has been at pains to acquire. If the Government now is of opinion that a knowledge of Mandarin on the part of an officer of this Government is not worth retaining it appears to me that Mr. May has a legitimate grievance. Only those who have had a practical experience of the task of learning Chinese can realize the amount of work necessary to attain the standard which Mr Hillier reports Mr. May has reached, and it seems to me that it will be a hardship to Mr. May, and a serious waste of public money if his labour is to be rendered nugatory. Mr. May is quite competent to perform his duties, but, as is well known to all who have acquaintance with Chinese, there is no European in Hong Kong who can dispense with the aid of a China expert or a teacher in translation work.

Page 360

Page 361

4

Edit History

2026-05-24 20:42:39 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
356 3 Poking had an object in view, and that object could have been none other than that he should require the Mandarin dialect. But surely it was never intended that Mr. May should be paid out of public funds - funds voted by the Legislative Council and the expenditure of which was approved by the Secretary of State - to devote more than to learning Mandarin only to unlearn it on his return to the Colony, for such will be the inevitable result if he is not assisted by the Government in keeping up the knowledge he has been at pains to acquire. If the Government now is of opinion that a knowledge of Mandarin on the part of an officer of this Government is not worth retaining it appears to me that Mr. May has a legitimate grievance. Only those who have had a practical experience of the task of learning Chinese can realize the amount of work necessary to attain the standard which Mr Hillier reports Mr. May has reached, and it seems to me that it will be a hardship to Mr. May, and a serious waste of public money if his labour is to be rendered nugatory. Mr. May is quite competent to perform his duties, but, as is well known to all who have acquaintance with Chinese, there is no European in Hong Kong who can dispense with the aid of a China expert or a teacher in translation work. Page 360 Page 361 4
Baseline (Original)
356 3 Poking had an object in view, and that C object could have been none other than that he should require the Mandarin dialect. But surely it was never intended that Mr. May should be paid out of public funds - funds voted by the Legislative Cornsil and the expenditure of which Avas approved by the Scoretary of State - to devote more than to learning Mandarin only to two years unlearn it on his return to the Colony, for such will be the inevitable result if 乡老 he is not assisted by the Government in Keeping up the Knowledge he has been at acquire. If the Government such pains to now is of opinion that a knowledge of mandarin on the part of an officer of this this Government is not worth retaining it appears to Ire that I. May has a legitimate grievance. Only those who_ have had a practical experience of the task of learning Chinese can realize. the amount of work necess to attain necessary to the standard which Mr Hillier reports to on Mr Mr. May has reached, and it seems me that it will be a hardship May, and a serious waste of public money if his labour is to be rendered regatory. Mr. May is quite competent to perform his duties, but, as is will Known to all who have acquaintance with Chinese, there is no European in HongKong who can Dispense with China or the aid of a teacher in translation work. The Page 360Page 361 4
2026-05-24 20:42:39 · Baseline
View content

356

3

Poking had an object in view, and that

C

object could have been none other than

that he should require the Mandarin dialect. But surely it was never intended that Mr. May should be paid out of public funds - funds voted by the Legislative Cornsil and the expenditure of which

Avas

approved by

the Scoretary of State - to devote more than to learning Mandarin only to

two

years

unlearn it on his return to the Colony,

for such will be the inevitable result if

乡老

he is not assisted by the Government in

Keeping up the Knowledge he has been at acquire. If the Government

such pains to

now is of opinion that a knowledge of mandarin on the part of an officer of

this

this Government is not worth retaining it appears to Ire that I. May has a legitimate grievance. Only those who_ have had a practical experience of

the task of learning Chinese can realize. the amount of work necess to attain

necessary to the standard which Mr Hillier reports

to

on Mr

Mr. May has reached, and it seems me that it will be a hardship May, and a serious waste of public money if his labour is to be rendered regatory. Mr. May is quite competent

to perform his duties, but, as is will Known to all who have

acquaintance with Chinese, there is no European in

HongKong who can

Dispense with

China or the aid of a teacher in translation work.

The

Page 360Page 361

4

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.